November 2008 Archives

Q2 - Lesson #21 - Unit #5 Identifications and Essay Exam

|
If you plan to word-process your identifications, you can download a copy of the
Unit #5 Identifications answer sheet.


REMINDER: You must finish the identifications before you leave class. Your essay should be printed out and turned in when you are finished. (You'll be asked to email me your essay if you are turning it in later in the day. Or, better yet, print it out and bring it to me.)


Unit #5 Identifications: You'll receive (or download) a handout from which you will write on your choice of 5 of the 8 identifications that appear. You may have 10 words of "notes" for each of the 15 possible identifications to the exam. You will need to turn in these notes, and I reserve the right to count symbols, acronyms, etc. as one or more words. Each of the five identifications is worth 5 points.

A good identification is typically in the range of 4 to 6 sentences in length. (You do need to write in complete sentences.) You should demonstrate both an understanding of just who / what the ID "is" and place it in the appropriate historical context. In addition, you need to explain the significance of the ID. In other words, answer the "So what?" question.


Unit #5 Essay Exam:

1. We considered the reigns of a number of absolute monarchs. Choose THREE specific monarchs and evaluate the impact of their reigns. Overall, was absolutism a positive or negative force in the Europe of the time?

2. The Enlightenment was a time of significant changes in thinking and values. Identify and evaluate the significance of what you consider to be the THREE most significant contributions of the Enlightenment. Which specific figure do you believe best embodied the spirit of the Enlightenment? Why?

3. We studied the causes of political revolution in places such as England, the American colonies, France, Haiti and Mexico. Choose THREE of these revolutions and evaluate whether each was justified. Which of the revolutions that you discuss do you believe was ultimately the most successful? Why?


Homework for next session - Monday, December 1st

Ms. Murr would tell you that only a real meanie assigns homework the night of the exam. I guess that makes me a meanie... (No complaining. You do have five days to get it finished.)

Please read Section 1 in Chapter 25, "The Beginnings of Industrialization." (pp. 717- 722) This is a relatively short quarter, so we need to keep going. (We are probably going to need to double up once on the reading as it is.)  The format for this quiz will be true/false.

Q2 - Lesson #20 - Unit #5 Objective Exam

|
It is a pretty straight-forward plan for today. You'll take the objective portion of the Unit #5 Exam. It has 60 multiple choice questions and 5 DBQs. 
Remember that your Current Events are now due. You can either email them as an attachment or print them out. 
Also, I need to be sure to get back your packet of reading quizzes that I returned for you to review.


HOMEWORK for tomorrow: Tuesday, November 25th


We'll have the Unit #5 Identifications exam tomorrow in class. Your essay is also due by the end of the day. You can find the essay questions and possible identifications here.

Q2 - Lesson #19 - Unit #5 "Two-Minute" Reviews

| | Comments (4)
We'll spend today doing our review activity. We'll get started right away so that we can get through this all.

UNIT 5:
Absolutism to Revolution (1500 - 1900)

Chapter 21: Absolute Monarchs in Europe (1500 - 1800)
1 Spain's Empire and European Absolutism
2 The Reign of Louis XIV
3 Central European Monarchs Clash
4 Absolute Rulers of Russia
5 Parliament Limits the English Monarchy

Chapter 22: Enlightenment and Revolution (1550 - 1789)
1 The Scientific Revolution
2 The Enlightenment in Europe
3 The Enlightenment Spreads
4 The American Revolution

Chapter 23: The French Revolution and Napoleon (1789 - 1815)
1 The French Revolution Begins
2 Revolution Begins Reform and Terror
3 Napoleon Forges an Empire
4 Napoleon's Empire Collapses
5 The Congress of Vienna

Chapter 24: Nationalist Revolutions Sweep the West (1789 - 1900)
1 Latin American Peoples Win Independence
2 Europe Faces Revolution
3 Nationalism
4 Revolutions in the Arts


HOMEWORK for next session - Monday, November 24th

Remember that your Current Events are now due no later than class time on Monday, November 24th.

You can either email them as an attachment or print them out. You can download a template on Lesson #15. There's more information on that lesson, and you can find an explanation of the world history themes on this page.

We'll have the Unit #5 Exam on Monday and Tuesday. Monday will be the the Objective Exam. On Tuesday, we'll have Identifications and the essay is due by the end of the day. That will consist of multiple choice questions and some document-based questions. You can find the essay questions and possible identifications here.

Q2 - Lesson #18 - MPA Romanticism and Realism Arts Festival

|
"Romanticism and Realism Arts Festival- Welcome. Today, we'll take some time to consider some of the new movements in the arts that we've been reading about. 

I was going to change the order a little, but I suppose we'll stick with this. It's the way they appear in the readings, so that might be helpful to you in terms of review, etc. Figure that no one should take more than five minutes for their presentation.
 
  • art of El Greco and Velazquez
  • Don Quixote de la Mancha by Miguel de Cervantes
  • art of Rembrandt van Rijn
  • Moliere's comedic plays
  • baroque art and architecture
  • music of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
  • music of Ludwig van Beethoven
  • British romantic poets (choose among Lord Byron, Percy Shelley, John Keats)
  • Les Miserables and The Hunchback of Notre Dame by Victor Hugo
  • Frankenstein by Mary Shelley
  • opera of Giuseppe Verdi and/or Richard Wagner
  • Louis Daguerre and the daguerreotype
  • works of Charles Dickens
  • art of Claude Monet
  • art of Edgar Degas
  • art of Pierre-Auguste Renoir  

HOMEWORK for tomorrow - Friday, November 21st

You are done with the reading for Unit #5. Congratulations.

Remember that your Current Events are due on Friday, but I'm taking them through class time on Wednesday with no penalty. You can either email them as an attachment or print them out. You can download a template on Lesson #15. There's more information on that lesson, and you can find an explanation of the world history themes on this page.

Your part of the Unit #5 Two-Minute Review should be ready to go for Friday.

We'll have the Unit #5 Exam on Monday and Tuesday. Monday will be the Objective Exam. That will consist of multiple choice questions and some document-based questions. On Tuesday, we'll have the Identifications and the essay is due.  You can find the essay questions and possible identifications here.

Q2 - Lesson #17 - The Rise of Nationalism

|
Since you've all got several things coming up, we'll make sure we stop whatever it is we are doing with at least a half-hour left in the block. Here's a reminder of what is coming up:

  • Thursday - "Romanticism and Realism Arts Festival"
  • Friday - Unit #5 "Two-Minute" Reviews, Current Events due
  • Monday - Unit #5 Objective Exam
  • Tuesday - Identification and Essay Exam
Following the quiz, we'll touch base on any questions you have regarding the test format. Then we'll return to nationalism for a bit, picking up a couple of specific examples.


The Rise of Nationalism
As we start, we'll have you spend about ten minutes with a DBQ packet that provides a nice overview. 

At the risk of incorrectly summarizing your thoughts, our class "definitions" from yesterday seemed pretty much along these lines.

The "critical attributes" of nationalism include:
  • loyalty to a nation is above other loyalties or individual interests
  • believing a certain group has a shared or collective identity
  • valuing a collective identity based on history, culture, language, race, and/or ethnicity
  • political claims (land, independence, sovereignty, etc.) are made on behalf of a defined nation

Now that we have this general consensus, let's look at the various types of nationalist movements. (We'll come back to this topic in future units...) I'm combining what our textbook has in the chart on page 692 with an excerpt from Michael Hechter at The Nationalism Project. Here's one version of a "typology" of nationalisms:

  • unification - merging politically divided but culturally similar lands
  • separation (or peripheral) - culturally distinct group resists being added to a state or tries to break away
  • state-building - culturally distinct groups form into a new state by accepting a single culture
  • irredentist - attempt to extend the boundaries of a state by incorporating territory of an adjacent state occupied principally by "co-nationals"

Let's see how we do with these different types. Try to classify each of these historical or current nationalist movements by type.

  • 19th century Italy and Germany
  • the early United States of America
  • 19th-20th century breakups of the Austrian and Russian empires 
  • current Iraq - Kurds, Sunni, Shiites
  • modern Tibet
  • advocates for "One" Korea
  • Russia's troop movements into Georgia this past summer
  • French-speaking citizens of Quebec
Some questions for you:
  • On balance, is nationalism a positive or negative force? Why?
  • Should patriotism be considered a type of nationalism?
  • Where in the modern world are we seeing the strongest forces of nationalism?
  • Does nationalism exacerbate problems of racism in the world? Why or why not?

Finally, we need to at least mention the most important aspects of the two classic stories of unification nationalism in 19th-century Europe: Italy and Germany.

Italy - Sardinia's King Victor Emmanuel II and his Prime Minister Camillo di Cavour drove the Austrians out of most of northern Italy with the help of the French. Giuseppe Garibaldi worked to unite the south before joining forces with the Sardinian King. Rome became the capital of a united Italy by 1870. (The pope kept control of what is know Vatican City.)

italy_nationalism.jpeg
Garibaldi is presenting "boot" of Italy to the king of Sardinia. (1860 British cartoon)


Germany - Here, the Prussian state led the process. Otto von Bismarck became prime minister in 1862. His "realpolitik" approach gave him near dictatorial powers, and he pledged to rule by "blood and iron." Wars with Austria and France rallied support of the German peoples, and the Second Reich was established in 1871 with Kaiser Wilhelm I in control.

bismarck_cartoon.jpg
Otto von Bismarck juggling images of war and peace on a see-saw labeled "European Politics" with powder keg and artillery piece visible. (1887 cartoon from US)

Want a challenge? Draw your own cartoon related to a historical or current example of nationalism. (Sounds like a good idea for some type of future assignment... This would be good practice for you.)


HOMEWORK for tomorrow - Thursday, November 20th

Please finish your reading in Chapter 24 (and Unit #5!) with Section 4, "Revolutions in the Arts." (pp. 698 - 701) The quiz is fill-in-the-blank.

Your contribution to the "Romanticism and Realism Arts Festival" needs to be ready to present tomorrow. I'll have the computer projector available, but you need to let me know if you need anything else.

Remember that your Current Events are due on Friday, November 21st. You can either email them as an attachment or print them out. You can download a template on Lesson #15. There's more information on that lesson, and you can find an explanation of the world history themes on this page.

Your part of the Unit #5 Two-Minute Review should be ready to go for Friday.

We'll have the Unit #5 Exam on Monday and Tuesday. Monday will be the Objective Exam. On Tuesday, we'll have the Identifications and Essay. That will consist of multiple choice questions and some document-based questions. You can find the essay questions and possible identifications here.

Q2 - Unit #5 Exam - Identifications and Essay Questions

|
Unit #5 Identifications: On Tuesday, November 25th, you will write on your choice of 5 of the 8 identifications chosen from the list below that appear on the Unit #5 exam. You may bring 10 words of "notes" for each of the 15 possible identifications to the exam. (Printed out; not on your computer.) You will need to turn in these notes, and I reserve the right to count symbols, acronyms, etc. as one or more words. Each of the five identifications is worth 5 points.  

A good identification is typically in the range of 4 to 6 sentences in length.  (You do need to write in complete sentences.)  You should demonstrate both an understanding of just who / what the ID "is" and place it in the appropriate historical context.  In addition, you need to explain the significance of the ID.  In other words, answer the "So what?" question.

Philip II
divine right
Louis XIV
Thirty Years' War
Oliver Cromwell
Galileo Galilei
social contract
John Locke
philosophe
enlightened despot
Reign of Terror
Napoleon Bonaparte
creoles
nationalism
Otto von Bismarck


Unit #5 Essay Exam - Questions and Format - You'll write an essay as part of the Unit #5 Exam. This essay will be due by the end of class on Tuesday, November 25th.  Below you can find both the questions from which you will choose and the format for the essay portion of the Unit #5 Exam. The essay is worth 30 points.

Format: The actual essay will be written, by hand or word-processed. You should prepare for a five-paragraph essay. That means that you should include an introduction (with a clear thesis statement), three body paragraphs, and a concluding paragraph. (Note that the questions lend themselves to such a format. That is on purpose.)  

Remember that the questions are not designed for you to tell us everything you have learned. Focus on what the question is requiring you to do.  NOTE: Some of you may have time on Monday to begin the essay in class. Others of you may begin working out of class. Because of this, there is no description of the "notes" you may or may not have. Due to the long break, I want the essays finished by the end of Tuesday.


1. We considered the reigns of a number of absolute monarchs. Choose THREE specific monarchs and evaluate the impact of their reigns. Overall, was absolutism a positive or negative force in the Europe of the time?

2. The Enlightenment was a time of significant changes in thinking and values. Identify and  evaluate the significance of what you consider to be the THREE most significant contributions of the Enlightenment. Which specific figure do you believe best embodied the spirit of the Enlightenment? Why?

3. We studied the causes of political revolution in places such as England, the American colonies, France, Haiti and Mexico. Choose THREE of these revolutions and evaluate whether each was justified. Which of the revolutions that you discuss do you believe was ultimately the most successful?  Why?

Q2 - Lesson #16 - The Beginnings of Nationalism

|
First up today will be some information about the Unit #5 exam that is scheduled for next Monday and Tuesday. You can find this on a separate blog entry... We'll also use this opportunity to draw for your Unit #5 Two-Minute Review assignments. Those will be due on Friday.


Finishing the "Atlantic Revolutions" - You were asked to do one of two very brief readings in preparation today. We'll start with those.

Revolutionary Rhetoric - Did it spread? You got a copy of a text produced by the leaders of one of two later revolutionary groups of the early twentieth century: the Young Turks and the Chinese revolutionaries. Consider these questions.

  • How does each document define liberty?
  • How does each document define citizenship?
  • What do the constitutions say about education?
We'll wrap up with a quick look at a map of Latin America and a brief consideration of the revolutions of 1848. If you want to know a lot more about the specifics on the 1848 Revolutions, you can check out this timeline. Timeline - Revolutions of 1848


The Rise of Nationalism - As you will read tonight, your textbook calls nationalism "the most powerful idea of the 1800s." We're going to work towards defining the concept today, and we'll look at the examples of Italy and Germany tomorrow.

I'm going to give you a handout with paragraphs of three examples of nationalism. I want to use these "case studies" to derive a definition of nationalism and its key attributes.

Let's compare notes and come up with a definition. We'll also throw in the concept of the nation-state and make a list of some of the results (positive and negative) of nationalism.

Finally, I'll have you consider the back side of the handout. Here are three more examples. In each case, evaluate whether or not we are talking about an example of nationalism here. We'll discuss these.


"Romanticism and Realism Arts Festival" - On Thursday, we'll take some time to consider some of the new movements in the arts that we've been reading about. You'll have a chance to share with us a topic of interest. (Some of these aren't technically part of either "Romanticism" or "Realism," but I like the alliteration in that title...)

You (or you and a partner) will choose from this list (or suggest another appropriate topic).

  • art of El Greco and Velazquez
  • Don Quixote de la Mancha by Miguel de Cervantes
  • art of Rembrandt van Rijn
  • Moliere's comedic plays
  • baroque art and architecture
  • music of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
  • music of Ludwig van Beethoven
  • British romantic poets (choose among Lord Byron, Percy Shelley, John Keats)
  • Les Miserables and The Hunchback of Notre Dame by Victor Hugo
  • Frankenstein by Mary Shelley
  • opera of Giuseppe Verdi and/or Richard Wagner
  • Louis Daguerre and the daguerreotype
  • works of Charles Dickens
  • art of Claude Monet
  • art of Edgar Degas
  • art of Pierre-Auguste Renoir
I'll have a projector available. Obviously, you can do music, visuals or whatever you find appropriate, but there should be something for us to listen to or see as appropriate. Figure that no one should take more than five minutes for their presentation. 


HOMEWORK for tomorrow - Wednesday, November 19th

Please continue your reading in Chapter 24 with Section 3, "Nationalism - Case Study: Italy and Germany." (pp. 692 - 697) The quiz is multiple choice.

Your contribution to the "Romanticism and Realism Arts Festival" needs to be ready to present on Thursday.

Remember that your Current Events are due on Friday, November 21st. You can either email them as an attachment or print them out. You can download a template on Lesson #15. There's more information on that lesson, and you can find an explanation of the world history themes on this page.

Your part of the Unit #5 Two-Minute Review should be ready to go for Friday.

We'll have the Unit #5 Exam on Monday and Tuesday. Monday, we'll have the Objective Exam. That will consist of multiple choice questions and some document-based questions. On Tuesday will be the Identifications and Essay.

Q2 - Lesson #15 - The Atlantic Revolutions

|
Here's a good example of the difference between a "Western Civilization" perspective and a "World History" perspective. Often, the American and French Revolutions are taught as the "culmination" of the Enlightenment. Here, however, we'll also be looking at a variety of revolutions throughout the "Atlantic World" during this time period. In particular, we'll add the Caribbean and Latin America to our attention today.

We'll test next Monday and Tuesday on Unit #5. I'll have more information available regarding the format tomorrow. Expect something very similar to last year.


Napoleon Acrostic: Let's see what you and your classmates posted on Lesson #14.

Current Events: I'm sure many of you were hoping that I forgot... I didn't. We'll do them a little bit differently this year. The Advanced Placement course in World History emphasizes five themes. (You'll remember that our text has a different list.) You can find a page with explanations of the themes of world history for more complete explanations. It's simple. You'll do five stories, one from each of the themes. Reading the subheadings under each theme should help you come up with plenty of ideas.

As with last year, you can download a Current Events template. You'll be expected to follow the format very closely. These are worth a total of 20 points. Current Events #1 will be due at the start of class on Friday, November 21st.


The Atlantic Revolutions - overview jigsawWe'll continue our look at the revolutions today. First, we are going to do a jigsaw focusing on the success of four particular revolutions in producing the ideas of liberty (freedom) and equality. The four revolutions we'll look at are: American, French, Haitian and Venezuelan revolutions.

First, you and a group will look at one of the revolutions. You'll evaluate how well it achieved the goals of freedom and equality.

Second, you'll hear about each revolution and complete a comparison activity.


After the Revolution - Now what?: It seems fair to evaluate whether the "revolutionaries" lived up to the promises of liberty they once called for once they have assumed power. It might be helpful to think of liberty both in terms of "political independence" and "personal freedom." Let's consider these questions:

  • Will the leaders want to restrict liberty for groups they view as threatening their own economic or political liberty: women, people of African descent, slaves, native peoples, some minority religious groups?
  • What would the leaders gain by restricting liberty?
  • What might they lose?

I'll provide you with some documents from each of the revolutions we have been considering. As you look at the documents, consider these questions.

1. How does each new government in the Atlantic world define citizenship?

2. What rights were guaranteed by the government and to which groups of people?

3. Which documents mention liberty?

4. How is slavery changed or maintained?

5. What kinds of powers does each new government assume? How are those powers divided among branches of government?


Revolutionary Rhetoric - Did it spread?: You'll get a copy of some texts produced by the leaders of two later revolutionary groups of the early twentieth century: the Young Turks and the Chinese revolutionaries. Your job is to read your set for tomorrow's class and be prepared to discuss these questions.

  • How does each document define liberty?
  • How does each document define citizenship?
  • What do the constitutions say about education?


HOMEWORK for tomorrow - Tuesday, November 16th

Please continue reading in Chapter 24 with Section 2, "Europe Faces Revolutions." (pp. 687 - 691) 

You should have read your excerpt (Turkey or China) for the "Revolutionary Rhetoric" exercise described above.

You have your first set of Current Events due on Friday, November 21st. The format is explained above. 

Q2 - Lesson #14 - The Rise and Fall of Napoleon

| | Comments (14)
The day will start with the pair of Napoleon quizzes.

We'll wrap up our look at the French Revolution and Napoleon today. Next week, our attention will turn to the waves of revolutions and nationalism that sweep the west, or the Atlantic world.


French Revolution - Cast of Characters
You were asked to "cast" the characters below using figures from a particular genre, profession, group or whatever. Ideally, your choices will help reveal your understanding of the roles these figures played in the French Revolution. Let's hear from some of you...

  • member of the First Estate
  • member of the Second Estate
  • member of the Third Estate
  • Jean-Jacques Rousseau
  • King Louis XVI
  • Marie Antoinette
  • Parisian woman rioting over bread prices
  • radical member of Legislative Assembly
  • moderate member of Legislative Assembly
  • conservative member of Legislative Assembly
  • Jean-Paul Marat
  • Charlotte Corday
  • Jacobin
  • Georges Danton
  • Maximilien Robespierre
  • Napoleon Bonaparte


The Political Spectrum - From Left to Right and In-Between Remember that the terms "left" and "right" to describe political views dates back to factions that sat together in the Legislative Assembly hall. Then, the "radicals" sat on the left, a term used today for those who typically are more in favor of change, the liberals. On the right were the "conservatives," the term we still use today for those more likely to want fewer changes. In the center were the moderates.

Let's take a minute to see where you fall. First, I'll show you a political spectrum and invite you to guess where you will end up. Then, you can take a quiz and see where your answers place you.  There are many versions on-line, but we'll take the "World's Smallest Political Quiz." (Note that the survey is hosted on a libertarian political site. The survey itself, however, is developed to be non-partisan and has been taken more than 11 million times. If you want to read a lot more about the methodology of the survey, go to their Frequently Asked Questions.) We'll walk through the questions together to make sure everyone understands them.


Napoleon: PBS Video - I've mentioned it before, but PBS really does an excellent job with their websites that accompany shows they produce. Here are some of the features from their series on Napoleon that you should check out.

  • Introduction: This is worth watching. It will get you to a menu when it ends.
  • Timeline: Key events with links to additional information.
  • Campaigns and Battles
  • Weapons and Units of the Grand Armee
  • Interactive Battlefield Simulator: Try to win the Battle of Waterloo. You can be either Napoleon or Wellington.
  • Perspectives on Napoleon: You can read what some people have to say about Napoleon.
  • Watch Napoleon Video Clips: You can pick from several scenes here.
  • Send a Napoleon Postcard: Who wouldn't want to receive one of these?
  •  

    Napoleon's Russia Campaign: As you read, Napoleon's invasion of Russia was perhaps his greatest military error. It took a tremendous toll, both actual and psychological, on his Grand Army. Fewer than 1 in 40 soldiers returned to France. The Russians, of course, also suffered great damage, both from the French forces and their own strategy of scorching the earth.

    We're going to take a look at the invasion by considering a single "information graphic," or chart, produced by Charles Minard in 1869. Edward Tufte of Yale University, perhaps the world's expert in information design, considers it "the best statistical graphic ever drawn."

    Image of Napoleon's Russia Campaign: Yes, this is in French. However, you should still be able to figure some things out from looking at this version.  

    Here's Tufte's description of what is happening.

    "Beginning at the left on the Polish-Russian border near the Niemen River, the thick band shows the size of the army (422,000 men) as it invaded Russia in June 1812. The width of the band indicates the size of the army at each place on the map. In September, the army reached Moscow, which was by then sacked and deserted, with 100,000 men. The path of Napoleon's retreat from Moscow is depicted by the darker, lower band, which is linked to a temperature scale and dates at the bottom of the chart. It was a bitterly cold winter, and many froze on the march out of Russia. As the graphic shows, the crossing of the Berezina River was a disaster, and the army finally struggled back into Poland with only 10,000 men remaining. Also shown are the movements of auxiliary troops, as they sought to protect the rear and the flank of the advancing army. Minard's graphic tells a rich, coherent story with its multivariate data, far more enlightening than just a single number bouncing along over time. Six variables are plotted: the size of the army, its location on a two-dimensional surface, direction of the army's movement, and temperature on various dates during the retreat from Moscow" (p. 40).

    Here are some "revisions" done to the graphic to try and show additional information or to clarify the information already there.

    Napoleon in Acrostic: An acrostic is a poem or other writing where the first letters of each line (or paragraph, etc. in some cases) spell out another message. For example:

    Kind hearted teacher of ninth-grade seminar
    Always trying to make everyone happy
    Teaching speech and debate
    Interesting and amusing conversationalist
    Excellent teacher and friend

    Miles away so I can make fun of her
    Unique and one-of-a-kind
    Really enjoying life in the Czech Republic

    Recently gave birth to her second son

    Your job: As you've probably guessed, you'll do one for Napoleon Bonaparte. Here's the wrinkle. "Napoleon" should all be about his background and/or rise to power. "Bonaparte" should all be about his decline and fall from power and/or his historical impact. You should post your acrostic as a comment on this entry.


    HOMEWORK for next session - Monday, November 17th  

    To keep on schedule, we're going to do something different with the final section from Chapter 23. I'm going to give you the quiz for Section 5, "The Congress of Vienna." (pp. 672 - 675) This quiz will be do at the beginning of the hour on Monday.

    Please begin your reading in Chapter 24, "Nationalist Revolutions Sweep the West," with Section 1, "Latin American Peoples Win Independence." (pp. 681 -  686) Of course, there will be a quiz you take during class.

    Your Napoleon Bonaparte acrostic should be posted before class time on Monday. Post as a comment to this entry. 

    We're still looking at the Unit #5 Exam on Monday, November 24th and Tuesday, November 25th. I'll have more information about the format by Monday's class.

    Q2 - Lesson #13 - The Revolution and the Terror

    |
    We'll continue with the French Revolution today... (No, you didn't miss a lesson. I combined parts of what I did first quarter from Lessons #11 and #12 with what we did yesterday.) Numbering this way makes it easier for me to keep things straight...


    DBQ Activity - We'll start things out giving you ten minutes to work through a DBQ activity on the French Revolution.

    The French Revolution - Chronology of Events: You were asked to draw a "fever chart" and place at least fifteen events/things from the French Revolution along the chart. We'll talk about what you've done. In addition, I've got another list for us all below so that we can check and see if we're at a similar point in our understanding of the model. (You can download a description of the Brinton model for revolutions if you need it.) We'll take a very short field trip to a location where we can build our own "fever chart" for these events.

    Old Regime rules France
    high taxes on nobles and peasants
    American Revolution occurs
    bad weather leads to grain shortages
    price of bread doubles
    King Louis XVI increases war debt
    Marie Antoinette becomes increasingly unpopular
    Estates-General meets for first time in 175 years (May 5, 1789)
    Third Estate becomes the National Assembly, drafts laws (June 17, 1789)
    Tennis Court Oath is taken (June 20, 1789)
    French mob storms the Bastille (July 14, 1789)
    Great Fear rolls through France (Summer/Fall 1789)
    National Assembly ends feudal privileges of 1st and 2nd Estates (August 4, 1789)
    Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen passed (August 1789)
    Parisian "women's march" over bread prices (October 1789)
    Louis and Marie Antoinette flee Versailles (October 1789)
    King and Queen caught trying to flee France (June 1791)
    New constitution; limits monarchy and creates Legislative Assembly (September 1791)
    War declared on Prussia and Austria (April 1792)
    September Massacres kill more than 1000 prisoners (September 1792)
    National Convention declares France a republic, ends monarchy (September 21, 1792)
    Jacobins try Louis XVI for treason; execute him (January 21, 1793)
    Maximilien Robespierre becomes leader of "Committee of Public Safety" (July 1793)
    "Reign of Terror" grips France (mid-1793 to mid-1794)
    Robespierre sent to the guillotine (July 28, 1794)
    Moderates create the Directory - giving power to upper middle class (1795)
    Napoleon protects Directory from royalist rebels (October 1795)
    Napoleon stages coup d'etat (November 1799)


    Remembering the French Revolution - You can get a good feel for the impact of the French Revolution when you see how many areas of art, literature, music and politics that it affected. We'll take quick looks at some of those.

    Human Rights
    Music
    Art and Images
    Literature
    • Charles Dickens' A Tale of Two Cities - You probably recognize this opening... (Download it all for free from Project Gutenberg if you want.) 

    "It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness, it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair, we had everything before us, we had nothing before us, we were all going direct to Heaven, we were all going direct the other way . . ."

    Speeches
    Contemporary Analysis
    • Edmund Burke was a British politician who severely criticized the revolution as early as 1790. Here's an excerpt. Skip down to the last paragraph.
    • American Thomas Paine responded with a defense of the French Revolution that he called, "The Rights of Man."


    French Revolution - Cast of Characters
    From Charles Dickens' A Tale of Two Cities to Les Miserables, the years surrounding the French Revolution and Napoleon have been frequently depicted in literature, film and on stage. Here's your chance to cast your own production. Below is a list of "characters" from this time period. Your job is to cast these parts by naming "actors" to play each role. The idea is that you'll make appropriate choices that show your understanding of these figures. You can select from history, literature, politics, film, music, television, mythology, MPA or whatever makes sense to you. "Bonus points" for casting with some sort of theme in mind. We'll have you share these cast lists and your rationale for them tomorrow.

    • member of the First Estate
    • member of the Second Estate
    • member of the Third Estate
    • Jean-Jacques Rousseau
    • King Louis XVI
    • Marie Antoinette
    • Parisian woman rioting over bread prices
    • radical member of Legislative Assembly
    • moderate member of Legislative Assembly
    • conservative member of Legislative Assembly
    • Jean-Paul Marat
    • Charlotte Corday
    • Jacobin
    • Georges Danton
    • Maximilien Robespierre
    • Napoleon Bonaparte


    HOMEWORK for tomorrow - Friday, November 14th 

    Tonight, you're asked to read BOTH Section 23:3 ("Napoleon Forges and Empire," pp. 663 - 667) and 23:4 (Napoleon's Empire Collapses," pp. 668 - 671). You'll have quizzes on each section, but I will allow you to bring in 50 words of notes for each if you would like. (That's for this pair of quizzes only.) 23.3 is matching and 23.4 is multiple choice.

    Have your cast of characters ready to share tomorrow.

    We're still looking at the Unit #5 Exam on Monday, November 24th and Tuesday, November 25th. I'll have more information about the format by Monday's class.

    Q2 - Lesson #11/12 - Revolution in America and France

    |
    We'll start by looking at the two exercises on the American Revolution that you worked on yesterday.

    The Road to the American Revolution
    Yesterday, you took a look at ten events on the "Road to the American Revolution." (Download a copy of the "Road to the American Revolution" worksheet if you weren't here.) In each case, you were asked to evaluate whether the particular act was justified by the side that carried it out. 

    1. British: In 1651, the British Parliament passed the Navigation Act. (textbook)
    2. British: In 1765, the British Parliament passed the Stamp Act.
    3. Americans: In the summer of 1765, the "Sons of Liberty" used a variety of tactics to undermine the Stamp Act.
    4. Americans: The colonists accuse the British King of "taxation without representation." (textbook)
    5. British: In 1770, British soldiers fire into a rioting crowd in what comes to be known as the "Boston Massacre."
    6. Americans: In 1773, a group of colonists dump a load of British tea in to Boston Harbor. (textbook)
    7. British: The port of Boston is closed down by the British navy in response to the "Boston Tea Party."
    8. Americans: In September of 1774, the First Continental Congress protests the treatment of Boston.
    9. BOTH: On April 19, 1775, gunfire is exchanged at Lexington and Concord. (textbook)
    10. Americans: In July of 1776, the Declaration of Independence is issued. (textbook)

    Underlying Causes of the Revolution
    We've hinted around this topic a bit, but let's confront it directly. 

    • What caused the American Revolution? 
    We have talked about specific events, but I want you to list underlying political, social and economic causes for the American Revolution. Think on this one.


    The Declaration of Independence
    You also worked on an activity related to the Declaration of Independence. You were asked to consider these questions/tasks:

    • As you read the document, identify its three main parts. They are the preamble, the list of grievances, and the formal declaration of war. Mark these parts somehow.
    • Thomas Jefferson chose to begin the Declaration with the words, "The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America." Do you feel this was necessary? Why or why not?
    • Find three examples of Thomas Jefferson's use of the ideas of the Enlightenment. Mark them.
    • What is Jefferson's view of the "social contract?" According to Jefferson, what was the purpose of government? What does Jefferson suggest should happen whenever government becomes "destructive of the ends for which it was created?" According to Jefferson, how do governments derive their powers?
    • Jefferson noted that "all men are created equal," suggesting that this was "self evident." Speculate as to what he meant by that statement. What sorts of conflicts and misconceptions may have stemmed from this statement?
    • Look at the list of grievances that Jefferson lists as reasons that the King has violated the natural rights of the colonists. Below, list the three grievances that you feel are the worst violations. Explain why you believe them to be important.
    • John Locke died in 1704, over 70 years before Jefferson wrote the Declaration of Independence. In your estimate, would Locke be happy with the way Jefferson used his Two Treatises to justify independence from Britain, which was Locke's native country? Why or why not?

    The Constitution and the Bill of Rights
    Yes, you've probably looked at the Constitution before. That's not an argument not to do it again... Browse these when you get a chance.

    • The Constitution - Here's a pretty interesting version. It is an original draft, but it shows any language that has been amended and/or superseded.
    • The Bill of Rights - Skim through the list and try to summarize each amendment briefly in your own words.
    • The Amendments - Yeah, it's Wikipedia, but it is also a list of the 27 amendments to the US Constitution.


    The French Revolution: Throughout the 18th century, France was generally considered the most advanced country in Europe. Through a combination of factors, they found themselves in the midst of a revolution and "reign of terror" as the century came to a close. We'll look at these events, as well as the rule of Napoleon which follows, from a variety of perspectives. Initially, we'll introduce a "model" for revolution and see how well it fits here.

    Crane Brinton - The Anatomy of Revolution In his 1938 book, Harvard historian Crane Brinton argued that a revolution was a process where power was overthrown and which passed through particular phases. He likened it to the process of a fever, leading some to call it a "fever chart" for revolution. In his book, he analyzed the English Civil War, American Revolution, French Revolution and Russian Revolution.

    You can download a description of the Brinton model for revolutions. I'll give you a handout with this description, as well as another, slightly different description of Brinton's stages of revolution. I'm also going to give you a larger sheet of paper. Working in a pair or on your own, I want you to test the model's value in analyzing the French Revolution. 

    • Read through the "phases and symptoms" on the handout.
    • Sketch out a fever chart on the paper provided for you.
    • Decide where you think the "phases" should fall along the fever chart.
    • Label your chart with at least fifteen (or more) specific events from Chapter 23's first two sections. (NOTE: You probably won't be all the way to the far, right end of your fever chart. The events from the time of Napoleon are yet to come.
    This should be ready for discussion tomorrow. Should you finish this early, go back and see how well the model fits what you know about the American Revolution.



    HOMEWORK for tomorrow - Thursday, November 13th
     

    Please continue your reading in Chapter 23, "The French Revolution and Napoleon." You'll have a quiz tomorrow on Section 2, "Revolution Brings Reform and Terror." (pp. 656 - 661)

    Note that Thursday night you'll be asked to read BOTH Section 23:3 and 23:4 for the next day. You'll have quizzes on each section, but I will allow you to bring in 50 words of notes for each section if you would like. (That's for this pair of quizzes only.)

    Q2 - Lesson #10 - From Enlightenment to Revolution

    |
    "Revolutions" will dominate our attention for the last couple weeks of this unit. We'll start by looking at the Enlightenment's influence on the American Revolution. Following that, we'll turn our attention to the French Revolution and a number of others.

    Here's an article some of you might find interesting. I'm guessing a few of you (at least) found the social contract discussion interesting. I'm also guessing a few of you like pirates. If any of you fit into BOTH categories, here's a Freakonomics blog entry: "Three Great Social Contractarians: Hobbes, Locke, and ... Blackbeard?"


    We'll return to our MPA Enlightenment Salon for a few moments. Overall, I thought there was a lot of interesting discussion. I'm curious as to what people have to say in response to these two questions:

    • Considering everything you have read and heard about thinking, arts, music, literature, etc., who do you believe is the individual who best epitomizes the spirit of the Enlightenment? Why?
    • If you were able to have lived the life of any figure from the Enlightenment, who would you choose? Why?

    The Enlightened Despots

    We will also take a few minutes to consider the emergence of a new type of ruler in the later part of the Enlightenment. These "enlightened despots" seemed to embrace much of the Enlightenment while not showing any indication of giving up power. We'll look briefly at this idea as embodied in three rulers: Frederick the Great of Prussia, Joseph II of Austria and Catherine the Great of Russia.

    A third of you will take a look at each of the three. We'll give you some time to figure things out, and then we'll compare notes. At the end, we'll look at the overall idea of the "enlightened despot."

    Download an Enlightened Despots study guide to organize your ideas. In addition to your textbook and Internet sources, you'll be asked to specifically consult one primary source from Paul Halsall's "Modern History Sourcebook," which is probably the most complete on-line collection of primary source material.

    Here are the links you'll need:
    Here are some concluding questions:
    • Is "enlightened despot" a contradiction in terms?
    • Which would tend to win out - "enlightenment" or "despotism?" Why?
    • Did the enlightened despots mark a meaningful change in leadership in Europe?
    We'll chat a bit more about Catherine the Great since she is such an interesting figure. Let's look at how she came to power, some of her most significant successes and failures, as well as the role her gender has played in her historical legacy.

    While we are at it: "Is the United States 'ready' for a female President?"


    The Road to the American Revolution

    We'll do several activities related to the American Revolution and its impact today and tomorrow. First, we'll take a look at the "Road to the American Revolution." Download a copy of the "Road to the American Revolution" worksheet which contains 10 events which helped lead up to the Revolution. In each case, you're asked to evaluate whether the particular act was justified by the side that carried it out. Many are discussed in your textbook, and I have provided specific links to a number of others. We'll talk about your assessments.

    1. British: In 1651, the British Parliament passed the Navigation Act. (textbook)
    2. British: In 1765, the British Parliament passed the Stamp Act.
    3. Americans: In the summer of 1765, the "Sons of Liberty" used a variety of tactics to undermine the Stamp Act.
    4. Americans: The colonists accuse the British King of "taxation without representation." (textbook)
    5. British: In 1770, British soldiers fire into a rioting crowd in what comes to be known as the "Boston Massacre."
    6. Americans: In 1773, a group of colonists dump a load of British tea in to Boston Harbor. (textbook)
    7. British: The port of Boston is closed down by the British navy in response to the "Boston Tea Party."
    8. Americans: In September of 1774, the First Continental Congress protests the treatment of Boston.
    9. BOTH: On April 19, 1775, gunfire is exchanged at Lexington and Concord. (textbook)
    10. Americans: In July of 1776, the Declaration of Independence is issued. (textbook)

    The Declaration of Independence
    You're certainly at least somewhat familiar with the Declaration of Independence. Today, we'll try to take a little bit different look at the document and its influences and impacts.

    First, you'll need a copy of the Declaration of Independence. Here's an online version. (Notice there are several versions and images of the Declaration on this site.) To complete the following tasks, however, you probably want to download a copy of the Declaration of Independence so that you can mark it as directed.

    Please answer these questions:

    • As you read the document, identify its three main parts.  They are the preamble, the list of grievances, and the formal declaration of war. Mark these parts somehow.
    • Thomas Jefferson chose to begin the Declaration with the words, "The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America." Do you feel this was necessary? Why or why not?
    • Find three examples of Thomas Jefferson's use of the ideas of the Enlightenment. Mark them.
    • What is Jefferson's view of the "social contract?" According to Jefferson, what was the purpose of government? What does Jefferson suggest should happen whenever government becomes "destructive of the ends for which it was created?" According to Jefferson, how do governments derive their powers?
    • Jefferson noted that "all men are created equal," suggesting that this was "self evident." Speculate as to what he meant by that statement. What sorts of conflicts and misconceptions may have stemmed from this statement?
    • Look at the list of grievances that Jefferson lists as reasons that the King has violated the natural rights of the colonists. Below, list the three grievances that you feel are the worst violations. Explain why you believe them to be important.
    • John Locke died in 1704, over 70 years before Jefferson wrote the Declaration of Independence. In your estimate, would Locke be happy with the way Jefferson used his Two Treatises to justify independence from Britain, which was Locke's native country? Why or why not?


    HOMEWORK for tomorrow - Tuesday, September 9th
     
    Please begin your reading in Chapter 23, "The French Revolution and Napoleon." You'll have a quiz tomorrow on Section 1, "The French Revolution Begins." (pp. 651 - 655)

    Note that Thursday night you'll be asked to read BOTH Section 23:3 and 23:4 for the next day. You'll have quizzes on each section, but I will allow you to bring in 50 words of notes for each if you would like. (That's for this pair of quizzes only.)

    Q2 - Lesson #9 - The Enlightenment

    |
    We'll turn our attention to the wider idea of the Enlightenment today. In addition to looking at the major contributions of Enlightenment thinkers and artists, we'll also focus on related issues in our world today.

    The MPA Enlightenment SalonWe will attempt to better understand some of the ideas and impacts of the Enlightment through a quasi-lame recreation of a salon. As you read for today, the salon was a social gathering, typically hosted by a woman of some wealth and means in Paris. Here, philosophes and others could discuss and share ideas.

    So, here's a problem. We need a European noble. Wait, I've got it. Ms. Katherine d'Murr is currently living in the Czech Republic. (Here's her blog if you want an update...) So, in our land of make believe, she'll be the dignified hostess for our salon... Now, we can begin.

    Format: You'll circulate at various times during our salon. We'll meet in six small groups. When you circulate, you need to be looking for different partners. At no time should more than two people be in a group two consecutive times. You'll be given a topic to discuss or another task. After a set amount of time, we'll come back together to hear what you think and move forward.


    Topic #1 - The Social Contract
    Let's make sure that everyone understands the differences between the views of Thomas Hobbes and John Locke. Once we have that straight, we'll have you form small groups to consider these questions:

    • Whose view of the social contract do you find more appropriate for the time in which these men lived? Why?
    • Whose view of the social contract do you believe is more appropriate for our modern world? For the United States? For Mounds Park Academy? Why?
    • What elements of each man's interpretation are reflected in modern American society?

    Topic #2 - Voltaire and Free Speech
    As you read, Voltaire was a brilliant satirist and a very influential philosophe. (You'll get to know him better in English 10...) For our purposes, we're going to look at his campaign for tolerance, particularly in the area of freedom of speech.

    His most famous quote is perhaps this one: "I do not agree with a word you say but will defend to the death your right to say it." Consider these questions:

    • In modern America, do we have too much freedom of speech? Too little? Provide examples to support your points.
    • What limits on the freedom of speech, if any, do you believe are appropriate?
    • As technology advances so rapidly, how can we balance freedom of speech with other concerns?

    CULTURE BREAK #1 - Changes in Artistic Styles
    The dominant artistic style in Europe during the 1600s and early 1700s was baroque. During the Enlightenment, a simpler and more elegant style known as neoclassical emerged. Browse at least five examples of baroque art and five examples of neoclassical art. Identify ways in which the styles differ. Decide which style you prefer and pick an example you like to show someone else.


    Topic #3 - Montesquieu and the Separation of Powers
    We'll touch base to make sure you are all familiar with the idea of the separation of powers advocated by Montesquieu. Consider these questions:

    • Do you think we truly have a separation of powers in our government today?  Do the "checks and balances" work? Why or why not?
    • Does the President of the United States have too much power?  Why or why not?

    Topic #4 - Jean Jacques Rousseau and Freedom
    Rousseau is known for his belief that, "Man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains." He advocated a form of direct democracy, believing that a good government would be freely formed and guided by the "general will" of the people. Consider these questions:

    • Do you share in Rousseau's belief in the basic goodness of people? Why or why not?
    • Do you agree with Rousseau that "civilization" (then or now) prevents people from realizing their natural goodness? Why or why not?
    • Is a society based on Rousseau's ideas feasible in modern times? Explain.

    CULTURE BREAK #2 - Denis Diderot's Encyclopedia
    As you read, Denis Diderot attempted to collect and publish the works of leading thinkers in his Encyclopedia. Browse this online version of Diderot's Encyclopedia (I'd recommend you browse "by English title of article.") Skim two or three excerpts to get a feel for his work.

     
    Topic #5 - Beccaria and the Criminal Justice System
    Italian philosophe Cesare Beccaria sought to reform the system used to try and punish criminals. He advocated for the abolishment of torture, cruel punishments and the right to a speedy trial. Consider these questions:

    • In America today, do criminals have too few protections or too many? Explain.
    • Is vengeance an acceptable value for a justice system? Why or why not?
    • Are there circumstances where the state is justified in using torture? Why or why not?
    • Is capital punishment consistent with the ideas of a modern justice system?

    Topic #6 - Mary Wollstonecraft and Women's Rights
    Although many during the time continued to believe men and women had distinct roles, writes like Mary Wollstonecraft helped advance the causes of women in a variety of areas. Consider these questions:

    • In America, does our education system treat men and women equally? Why or why not?
    • Are there still meaningful barriers to equality for women in politics? Explain.
    • Fifty years from now, will Americans still be talking about a "gender gap?" Why or why not?

    Closing the MPA Enlightenment Salon: As we close, I have a couple of questions for you to ponder.

    • Considering everything you have read and heard about thinking, arts, music, literature, etc., who do you believe is the individual who best epitomizes the spirit of the Enlightenment? Why?
    • If you were able to have lived the life of any figure from the Enlightenment, who would you choose? Why?


    HOMEWORK for tomorrow - Tuesday, November 11th

    Please finish your reading in Chapter 22 with Section 4, "The American Revolution." (pp. 640 - 645) We'll be back to multiple choice for the reading quiz.

    Q2 - Lesson #8 - The Scientific Revolution(?)

    |
    After the reading quiz on the Enlightenment, you'll turn your attention to the events referred to as the "Scientific Revolution." Not everyone agrees that this is an appropriate term. You'll receive a handout to read for Monday, and I'd like you to consider this question:

    Should the term "Scientific Revolution" be replaced by the term "Scientific Evolution" to best explain the development of modern science?

    Related questions:
    • Have the contributions of non-European Afroeurasians been given too little credit for advancements in science? If so, was this lack of credit intentional? Why or why not?
    • Do we pay too little attention to the scholars of the medieval period? Why or why not?
    • Is there a European bias in the history of science? Why or why not?
    We'll discuss this briefly on Monday.


    "Experiments" in the history of scienceWe're going to have you work in groups on a series of tasks here. Please work in groups of at least three and no more than five. I'd recommend everyone take some notes, or get a copy of the group's notes. I will expect each group to give/email me a copy of your notes.

    First, I want your group to think about just what science is. Assume that you are going to be talking to my daughter's kindergarten class. If you had two minutes, what would you tell them science "is"? Make some notes and be prepared to share them with the big group.

    Second, I want you to think about what it is that separates "science" from "not science." Do some brainstorming here. It might help you to think in terms of some of the following:
    • subject matter
    • theory and hypothesis
    • methods of observation and/or investigation
    Third, considering what you know about history, I want you to think about the historical conditions and events that you believe would either promote or hinder the development and spread of science. (Some categories of events and/or conditions might include:  political, social, economic, religious, technological, intellectual conditions, etc.)

    Fourth, you'll look at some documents in "Was There Science Before the Scientific Revolution?" You'll get a collection of documents spanning the time from the 10th to the 14th centuries. They are from a variety of Islamic and European authors.

    As you take a look at these documents, consider the following:
    • What kinds of support and/or evidence are used by the authors to support their conclusions?
    • Based on the documents, what would you consider to the 3-5 most distinctive characteristics of the science of the medieval period?
    • If you were to award a Nobel Prize to the "Outstanding Medieval Scientist," whom would you select? Why?

    Fifth, you'll look at a parallel set of documents from the 16th-18th centuries in "Science Comes of Age: Was It a Revolution?" These are from European sources.

    As you take a look at these documents, consider the following:
    • What kinds of support and/or evidence are used by the authors to support their conclusions? In what ways is this different from the medieval period?
    • Based on the documents, what would you consider to the 3-5 most distinctive characteristics of the science of 16th-18th Century Europe?
    • If you were to this time award a Nobel Prize to the "Scientist Who Best Represents the Ideals of Modern Science," whom would you select? Why?


    Galileo Galilei - A Case Study: As you read, Galileo's observations published in Starry Messenger seemed to refute the theories of Aristotle while confirming the theories of Copernicus. The Catholic Church, defending Ptolemy's view of a geocentric system, warned Galileo not to continue these studies. In 1632, he published Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems, clearly favoring the ideas of Copernicus over Ptolemy. Galileo was summoned by the Pope to stand trial before the Inquisition. Under threat of torture, Galileo renounced his own work.

    You can read the original documents here: The Crime of Galileo - Indictment and Abjuration of 1633. Galileo lived under house arrest outside Florence for the last nine years of his life. Interestingly, in 1992, the Catholic Church acknowledged that Galileo had been correct. You can read a New York Times account of this here: After 350 Years, Vatican Says Galileo Was Right: It Moves.


    HOMEWORK for next session - Monday, November 10th:

    Please continue in your reading on the Enlightenment with Chapter 22, Section 3, "The Enlightenment Spreads." (pp. 636 - 639)

    Read the handout you received at the beginning of the hour and consider the questions at the top of the blog entry.
    Obviously, we can talk some election news today. You'll only have one "day after the U.S. Presidential election" in high school...
    We'll start off with the quiz on "The Scientific Revolution" before we move back into our trial activity. Remind me also to briefly mention the other activities on the English Civil War on yesterday's blog entry that we did not get to...


    "Absolute Monarchs on Trial" - We'll pick up where we left off. Any remaining prosecution witnesses will testify first. Following that, we'll hear from the defense witnesses and the defendants themselves. Here's a roster of those folks:

    First up will be any prosecution witnesses we may have missed.

    We'll continue with these defense witnesses:
    • Cardinal Richelieu
    • Jean Baptiste Colbert
    • Thomas Hobbes
    • Niccolo Machiavelli
    Then, we'll hear from the six defendants:

    • Philip II of Spain (King)
    • Louis XIV of France (King)
    • Maria Theresa of Austria (Empress)
    • Frederick the Great of Prussia (King)
    • Peter the Great of Russia (Czar)
    • Charles I of England (King)
    After the testimony, all of you but the six monarchs now become jurors. You are freed from your earlier perspective. As we move into deliberations, keep in mind that you can ask questions of our monarchs as well.

    I'll provide you with a sheet to use as an aid in our deliberations.


    The Scientific Revolution and the Enlightenment

    Our next major focus will be on the time period known as the "Enlightenment" in Europe.  Following the lead of our text, we'll initially look at the groups of changes referred to as the "Scientific Revolution."

    As you read for today, Europeans made some truly impressive advancements during the time known as the "Scientific Revolution." We're going to start by taking a step back and discuss whether or not they are getting too much credit. Alternately, you might ask whether non-Europeans are getting too little credit for their contributions.

    I'm giving you a broad overview in the form of a handout. It takes a slightly different look at these events than did your textbook. As you read it, consider this question:

    Should the term "Scientific Revolution" be replaced by the term "Scientific Evolution" to best explain the development of modern science?

    Related questions:
    • Have the contributions of non-European Afroeurasians been given too little credit for advancements in science? If so, was this lack of credit intentional? Why or why not?
    • Do we pay too little attention to the scholars of the medieval period? Why or why not?
    • Is there a European bias in the history of science? Why or why not?

    HOMEWORK for tomorrow - Thursday, November 6th:

    Please continue your reading with Chapter 22, Section 2, "The Enlightenment in Europe."  (pp. 629 - 634)

    (If we get this far...) Read the handout, "Scientific Revolution or Scientific Evolution?" and be prepared to contribute to a discussion on the topic listed above.

    Q2 - Lesson #6 - English Civil War / Absolute Monarchs on Trial

    |
    Today's main focus will be "Absolute Monarchs on Trial." We'd like to hear from all of the prosecution witnesses today. Before we start the trial, however, we'll touch base of the events that took place in England in your last reading.

    The English Civil War:  We'll take a look at these events from the perspective of a British student below. For now, however, let's be sure that you are clear on the main points from this section.

    • The British monarchs and Parliament had long struggled over issues of money and debt.
    • Charles I grew increasingly unpopular as he imposed heavy fees and fines on the people.
    • In 1641, Parliament tried again to limit the King's power.
    • From 1642-1649, the English Civil War was fought
      • Those supporting Charles were called Royalists or Cavaliers.
      • Those opposing the King were the Puritans also called "Roundheads."
    • The forces of Parliament gained the upper hand under Oliver Cromwell and his New Model Army.
    • In 1649, Charles was put on trial for treason and publicly executed.
    In the years after the English Civil War, there were several more events worth noting.

    • Oliver Cromwell ruled England as a sort of military dictator from 1649 to 1658.
    • The Puritans tried to bring many reforms to English society.
    • Charles II (son of Charles I) was offered the crown in the "Restoration."
      • Parliament passed a habeas corpus law in 1679.
      • Charles had no heir, so power passed to his Catholic brother James II.
    • William and Mary ended fears of a line of Catholic monarchs in the Glorious Revolution of 1688.
    • England became a constitutional monarchy, and the office of prime minister came to hold the power of policy making for the country.


    "Absolute Monarchs on Trial"


    THE CHARGES:  The Absolute Monarchs of Europe are charged with: ignoring the needs and well-being of the people, bankrupting the state, pursuing selfish foreign policies and harming the futures of their states.

    First, an introduction of the six defendants:

    • Philip II of Spain (King)
    • Louis XIV of France (King)
    • Maria Theresa of Austria (Empress)
    • Frederick the Great of Prussia (King)
    • Peter the Great of Russia (Czar)
    • Charles I of England (King)

    Today, we'll hear the testimony of these prosecution witnesses:
    • Dutch merchant
    • Spanish sailor from the Armada
    • French peasant
    • French soldier from War of Spanish Succession
    • French nobleman
    • Patriarch of the Russian Orthodox Church
    • Russian serf
    • Russian laborer building St. Petersburg
    • Oliver Cromwell
    • Member of English Parliament

    Tomorrow, we'll begin with the defense witnesses:
    • Cardinal Richelieu
    • Jean Baptiste Colbert
    • Thomas Hobbes
    • Niccolo Machiavelli

    Evaluation
    : As mentioned, all witnesses are expected to have a speech of at least two minutes. In this speech, it should be made clear why you oppose/support the idea of absolute monarchy, as well as one or more of the specific absolute monarchs. Your story can be creative, but it should also be consistent with reality. In addition, you will receive credit for being an active participant in questioning and deliberating.  (The speeches of the six defendants can be more centered on the issue of how each ruler made effective use of their power as absolute monarch for the good of their country.)


    The English Civil War "Across the Pond": We'll take a quick look at the English Civil War as it might be studied over in Great Britain. I've found some online resources largely designed for students in "Year 8," meaning they are 11 and 12. Sounds like you should be able to handle them...

    War - This is a pretty interesting site put together by a British television station. You can find a lot here by browsing around.

    The Long Term Causes of the Civil Wars:  You don't need to do the cutting and sorting to understand this activity. Instead, look at examples of how the causes fell into the categories of money, religion and Parliament.

    The English Civil War: You might learn a little by doing these activities, but you'll probably mostly learn that you are glad not to be in the British equivalent of middle school...

    What sort of man was Oliver Cromwell? - This is a sort of DBQ type activity. You don't need to answer the questions, but reading the sources will give you a feel for some various perspectives on Oliver Cromwell.


    HOMEWORK for tomorrow - Wednesday, November 5th:

    Please start your reading in Chapter 22.  Read Section 1, "The Scientific Revolution." (pp. 623 - 628)  We'll keep doing the quizzes.

    We'll conclude our "Absolute Monarchs on Trial" simulation tomorrow, so be ready to present if you have yet to do so. Of course, everyone should be ready to ask questions and deliberate as well.

    Q2 - Lesson #5 - Russia's Absolute Rulers

    |
    Although I'd like to think I did a pretty good job of staying away from doing a lot of unnecessary lecturing in the World History 9 course last year, you need me to cut a little bit of slack today.  Russian history is one of my favorite areas, and I've got a lot of pretty good stories to share with you.  After our quiz, we'll look at the two classic examples of the Russian czar, or absolute ruler: Ivan the Terrible and Peter the Great.


    Ivan the Terrible-  A fascinating figure, Ivan the Terrible was the first Russian ruler to formally use the term, "czar."  Download a copy of these From Ivan to Peter notes, and we'll walk through his life, as well as the period of chaos that followed it.  

    The Time of Troubles - While it is certainly not the most important period in Russian history, I think the years after the death of Ivan the Terrible are bizarre enough to deserve our attention for a couple minutes. For many of you, it will be a chance to show us your dramatic skills...

    Impact of Peter the Great
    - This list is by no means complete, but it shows the time line of some major events from the time of Peter the Great.

    1695-96 capture of Azov
    1695 beginning of Russian navy
    1696 death of Ivan V; Peter assumes full power
    1697-98 Peter's "Grand Embassy" to the West
    1698 Streltsy revolt crushed
    1700 suspension of patriarchate, new calendar
    1700-21 Great Northern War with Sweden
    1709 victory in Battle of Poltava
    1713 capital moved to St. Petersburg
    1718 Tsarevich Alexis killed
    1721 treaty with Sweden- new lands acquired
    1722 Table of Ranks established, succession law
    1725 death of Peter the Great

    How did Peter alter the future of Russia?

    * Westernization campaign- "Window to the West"
    * modernization of military
    * bringing of industry and technology to Russia
    * introduction of Russia navy
    * ends mestnichestvo- system of precedence
    * secularization of Russian state and culture
    * spiritual regulation- seizure of lands, suspends the Patriachate
    * "Truth of the Monarch's Will"- attempts to end question of succession
    * establishment of St. Petersburg


    HOMEWORK for tomorrow - Tuesday, November 4th

    Please read the final section in Chapter 21, "Parliament Limits the English Monarchy." (pp. 614 - 617)

    We'll begin our "Absolute Monarchs on Trial" activity on Tuesday with the testimony from the prosecution witness.  Here's a reminder about the specifics for the assignment.

    THE CHARGES:  The Absolute Monarchs of Europe are charged with: ignoring the needs and well-being of the people, bankrupting the state, pursuing selfish foreign policies and harming the futures of their states.

    FORMAT:  All witnesses should be prepared to give a "speech" in class.  This should be between 2 and 3 minutes. It need not be memorized. If you are a real person, you should explain why "you" support a particular monarch and/or the idea of absolutism. If you represent a "type" of person, you should create a story consistent with your assigned side and background. Prosecution witnesses may focus on one or more of the charges against a particular monarch. 

    The six monarchs will have two roles. First, they can question the witnesses for the two sides. In addition, they will have a chance to address the jury before deliberation begins.  (All the witnesses become the "jury" at this stage.) In this address, each monarch has between 3 and 4 minutes to summarize his or her accomplishments as a monarch and/or explain why they should not be convicted of the charges. Our jury will then deliberate on the fate of each monarch, and they also can ask questions of the monarchs at this point. (Note that there may well be different verdicts in the different cases.)

    EVALUATION:  You will receive credit for both your "speech" and your participation/conduct during the rest of the trial.

    Here are the roles we'll have:

    DEFENDANTS:
    Philip II of Spain (King)
    Louis XIV of France (King)
    Maria Theresa of Austria (Empress)
    Frederick the Great of Prussia (King)
    Peter the Great of Russia (Czar)
    Charles I of England (King)

    DEFENSE WITNESSES:
    Cardinal Richelieu
    Jean Baptiste Colbert
    Thomas Hobbes
    Niccolo Machiavelli

    PROSECUTION WITNESSES:
    Dutch merchant
    Spanish sailor from the Armada
    French peasant
    French soldier from War of Spanish Succession
    French nobleman
    Patriarch of the Russian Orthodox Church
    Russian serf
    Russian laborer building St. Petersburg
    Oliver Cromwell
    Member of English Parliament

    About this Archive

    This page is an archive of entries from November 2008 listed from newest to oldest.

    October 2008 is the previous archive.

    December 2008 is the next archive.

    Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.